Date:Sunday August 26 2007
Sir Alex Ferguson believes Nani's powerful shot could have been a goal anyway but the deflection on Tevez's head made it absolutely certain.
Therefore, he says the goal should be awarded to Tevez.
"Carlos Tevez`s touch on the ball decided," he told Sky Sports.
"It may have gone in anyway because it was such a ferocious hit. But, personally, I think it`s Tevez`s goal, being a centre-forward."
There are two things wrong with it. First, a shot of such power and accuracy deserves a goal and Nani should not be deprived of the glory of hitting a vital winner in only his fourth competitive outing for United.
Secondly, Tevez actually pulled his head down, trying to get out of the shot's way - his touch was unintended. For me, it's Nani's goal and surely the vast majority of people will say the same.
And the spicy matter: the penalty appeal. I think it was Brown's chest and though it's true he dived like a keeper, his arm was very much close to his body and it did not reach for the ball. Martin Jol is wrong in saying he did everything as a keeper - no, he acted as a defender desperate to clear. It is possible that the ball hit his arm but it was unintended and meant to clear with his chest.
In this case I agree with Fergie: it hit Brown's chest.
"At the time they protested so much that I thought it must have been a penalty," he said.
"But I`ve it, it`s clear, and Wes said himself that it hit him on the chest. As it hits him, his arm comes out so maybe that`s why they thought it hit his arm. But I`m sure of it, it hit his chest."
If Jol says we were lucky, he's right. If he says they played well, he's right. If he says they would have deserved a point, he's right. But it was not a penalty.
Date:Sunday August 26 2007
Lewandowski Hankers After Bayern Move (Still) (Monday June 17 2013)
Relief from the Boredom! (Monday June 17 2013)
Does Anyone Remember Bebe? (Monday June 17 2013)
Linked to Arsenal Move! (Monday June 17 2013)
Buttner and Homesickness! (Sunday June 16 2013)
City Are Interested As Well! (Sunday June 16 2013)
Is Powell Surplus to Requirements? (Sunday June 16 2013)
Rooney Tops Poll (Sunday June 16 2013)
Money Isn`t the Most Important of Things (Sunday June 16 2013)
Banging Your Own Drum? (Saturday June 15 2013)
|Man Utd||3||-||0||Aston Villa|
|West Ham||2||-||2||Man Utd|
|1. Man Utd||38||28||5||5||+43||89|
|2. Man City||38||23||9||6||+32||78|
|Kinnear In Car Crash Drama
» Newcastle : 17/06/2013 22:58:00
|Toivonen To Talk To City
» Norwich : 17/06/2013 19:50:00
|Newcastle United Is Dying
» Newcastle : 17/06/2013 19:45:00
|Liverpool: Reds Looking To Land Cissokho
» Liverpool : 17/06/2013 18:34:00
|A New Mind-Set.
» Chelsea : 17/06/2013 18:07:00
|Reid Agrees 12 Month Extension
» WBA : 17/06/2013 17:55:00
|Pre Season Ticket Latest
» Aston Villa : 17/06/2013 17:26:00