Date:Sunday August 26 2007
Sir Alex Ferguson believes Nani's powerful shot could have been a goal anyway but the deflection on Tevez's head made it absolutely certain.
Therefore, he says the goal should be awarded to Tevez.
"Carlos Tevez`s touch on the ball decided," he told Sky Sports.
"It may have gone in anyway because it was such a ferocious hit. But, personally, I think it`s Tevez`s goal, being a centre-forward."
There are two things wrong with it. First, a shot of such power and accuracy deserves a goal and Nani should not be deprived of the glory of hitting a vital winner in only his fourth competitive outing for United.
Secondly, Tevez actually pulled his head down, trying to get out of the shot's way - his touch was unintended. For me, it's Nani's goal and surely the vast majority of people will say the same.
And the spicy matter: the penalty appeal. I think it was Brown's chest and though it's true he dived like a keeper, his arm was very much close to his body and it did not reach for the ball. Martin Jol is wrong in saying he did everything as a keeper - no, he acted as a defender desperate to clear. It is possible that the ball hit his arm but it was unintended and meant to clear with his chest.
In this case I agree with Fergie: it hit Brown's chest.
"At the time they protested so much that I thought it must have been a penalty," he said.
"But I`ve it, it`s clear, and Wes said himself that it hit him on the chest. As it hits him, his arm comes out so maybe that`s why they thought it hit his arm. But I`m sure of it, it hit his chest."
If Jol says we were lucky, he's right. If he says they played well, he's right. If he says they would have deserved a point, he's right. But it was not a penalty.
Date:Sunday August 26 2007
Villa to Do Permanent Deal for Cleverley (Sunday December 21 2014)
United Linked to a Trio of Midfield Talent (Sunday December 21 2014)
United Interest in Bale Re-Ignited (Sunday December 21 2014)
Two Points Dropped! (Saturday December 20 2014)
Stats: Aston Villa v United (Saturday December 20 2014)
Van Gaal Frustrated with Draw at Villa Park (Saturday December 20 2014)
Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 (Saturday December 20 2014)
Aston Villa v United - Team Sheets (Saturday December 20 2014)
Van Gaal Makes Carrick United Vice-Captain (Saturday December 20 2014)
11 of the Best for Villa (a) (Saturday December 20 2014)
|Aston Villa||1||-||1||Man Utd|
|Man Utd||3||-||0||Hull City|
|2. Man City||17||12||3||2||+22||39|
|3. Man Utd||17||9||5||3||+12||32|
|4. West Ham||17||9||4||4||+10||31|
|Villa to Do Permanent Deal for Cleverley
» Man Utd : 21/12/2014 13:28:00
|United Linked to a Trio of Midfield Talent
» Man Utd : 21/12/2014 13:18:00
|United Interest in Bale Re-Ignited
» Man Utd : 21/12/2014 13:10:00
|The Ped Report.. City 3-0 Crystal Palace
» Man City : 21/12/2014 12:52:00
|Tyne-Wear Derby: Team News
» Sunderland : 21/12/2014 12:50:00