UK time is: 14:22:35
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Greatest Ever United... Really?

Sir Alex Ferguson claims this is the most talented squad he's ever managed. Is it really?

Nani, Anderson, Owen Hargreaves, Carlos Tevez. Not bad names to add to a championship-winning side, already boasting players like Wayne Rooney, Cristiano Ronaldo, Paul Scholes, Ryan Giggs and Louis Saha.

Sir Alex is well within his rights to claim he's never had a better squad at his disposal. And there are plenty of arguments to suggest it's true.

Between the sticks, Van der Sar's been impressive ever since he had joined from Fulham but never reached the brilliance of Peter Schmeichel. The defense is as solid as ever - and less prone to lapses of concentration than even the famous Bruce-Pallister partnership. On skill, Rio and Vidic are far superior than their predecessors but not as tough and intimidating.

Patrice Evra, while showing great promise, has to do awfully much to be compared to the great Denis Irwin but on the other flank, Gary Neville's been in the form of his life last season and he's undoubtedly United's greatest ever right-back.

Midfield. Now that's tricky. I'd say that the Beckham-Scholes-Keane-Giggs quartet is unsurpassable, it's the best midfield of the past 20 years or so. Kanchelskis, Sharpe, Ince, Robson with Keane and Giggs again come close to it, as the famous 1994 side dominated almost all of their opponents with this intimidating set of players.

And the current one? Ronaldo is brilliant yet still inconsistent, Scholes has improved with age (not his tackling though), Michael Carrick is a type of player we've never had - a silky passer as a defensive midfielder. Owen Hargreaves could turn out to be a huge success and I have faith in him - comparing him to Roy Keane is a mistake, he's much rather like Paul Ince, a telling tackler but not such a forceful personality as the Irishman.

Giggs has widened the range of his skills recently and is still great for us, I have no doubts about that. The new signings, Anderson and Nani add even more technical excellence to the squad but are unproven in England. The potential and the talent is there, though.

Up front. Forget Eric Cantona, he's the one and only striker, we'll never have another Eric just as we'll never have another Roy Keane. In terms of understanding each other, the Cole-Yorke partnership is unbeatable, just as Canto is in terms of sheer brilliance. Yet the current crop, in terms of talent, stands up to any comparison: Rooney, Tevez, Saha are all technically excellent and the former two have fantastic fighting spirit, something Fergie always valued.

Squad depth: I think it'd be hard to argue that we never had such a big squad. We have cover in every position and will have quality players on the bench to turn matches if we need to.

So what's the verdict? I think such comparisons are difficult to make. In terms of technique and skills, this team is head and shoulders above any previous ones. So I might agree with Fergie that this is the most talented squad he's ever had. However, I'd strongly argue that this does not mean that it is the best ever the squad he's had. That would mean we are obliged to win the Quadruple, something that's very, very unlikely to happen.

As all of his best teams, this one will be able to attack at pace and tear opponents apart with skill. The defense is solid and we have better goalkeepers than we've ever had since the departure of the Big Dane. However, there's one more thing. It might sound obvious but it's relevant: football has changed dramatically since Fergie's first great team. The 1994 and even the 1999 teams encountered different opponents, faced different challenges. And that makes comparisons almost impossible though I'd like to think I made a valiant effort to do it*.

But of course its achievements that can tell great teams apart. If we win the Premiership and the Champions League, I'll be forced to conclude that this is Fergie's greatest ever team, for such a feat would be more impressive than the 1999 Treble - and more difficult, I think.

*Modesty might not be my strongest point




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: Zae Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday August 6 2007

Time: 2:21PM

Your Comments

u sure get a lot of replies from fellow mancs. on the topic, the only aspect that this united has an upper hand on the old one is squad depth.
G4L
time will tell ?
Eddie01
It surely will, Eddie.
Zae
i think you will if Tevez does actualy sign
upthedale
Surely nothing could block that now, upthedale? Though one might have a point when saying that anything could happen in that transfer...
Zae
All good deals for Utd, bar Tevez. The Guy is all hype I tell you.
adztheyid
And what makes you say that, dear Yid? Would love to hear your reasons.
Zae
not sure about best ever. surely have to do the treble again for that??? not sure about tevez either. got the ability as shown in 2nd half of season at west ham, but just not sure about him
daspecial1
No offence but I can't really say why people say they are unsure about Tevez. I think ANY new signing is unsure to succeed, you can never say it for certain - so it's not something special that you have doubts about Tevez. I had doubts about Rooney and Yorke and Cole and Sheringham. Not because I'm stupid (or not ONLY because of that) but because you can never know.
midlothian99
i dont know i dont think it is the greatest ever but has the potential in 2 or 3 years with all our new young lads rooney ronaldo tevez nani anderson pique evans gibson
allred
rooney and tevez im sure will be great, but i think they will need to go a long way to beat the cole-yorke partnership
united4life
I think he's just raising expectation in his players, he makes comments like those. And all his players puff their chest out, and try to live upto his expectation
Topspur1
people will be expecting too much from man utd this year and i dont think some of the players will be able to handle the added pressure. everyone is expecting a really strong united and altought they will win the league this year i think it may be the only thing they win, perhaps the fa cup. on the other hand when you look at the competion in the cl there are no teams that any1 should really fear so united have as goood a chance as any.
rk1888
i just dont think that the rooney-tevez partnership will hit it off. i feel they're too similar with their style of play
daspecial1
rk1888, if we indeed win "only" the league, I'll be absolutely satisfied - unlike Fergie, I'm not obsessed with the European Cup :-)
midlothian99
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

And Another Bites the Dust (Wednesday April 16 2014)

Carvalho Has Another Suitor! (Tuesday April 15 2014)

Duo Fined and Warned! (Tuesday April 15 2014)

No Darren, No! (Monday April 14 2014)

I Should be Used More Claim! (Monday April 14 2014)

No Smoke without Fire Syndrome (Monday April 14 2014)

Thanks But No Thanks! (Monday April 14 2014)

Giggs - Preparing to Call Time? (Sunday April 13 2014)

Van Gaal Talk! (Saturday April 12 2014)

Spanish Interest in Hernandez! (Saturday April 12 2014)

Archived Articles

List All Vital United Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. TheFamousNo7 53
2. Kanchelskis 37
3. MotorMad 26
4. gmauti 3
5. kresek 2
6. nordkap 2
7. Xfunny 1
8. Javan 1
9. ForeverUnited 1

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Newcastle 0 - 4 Man Utd
Man Utd 4 - 1 Aston Villa
Man Utd 0 - 3 Man City
West Ham 0 - 2 Man Utd
Man Utd 0 - 3 Liverpool
WBA 0 - 3 Man Utd

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
4. Arsenal 34 20 7 7 18 67
5. Everton 33 19 9 5 22 66
6. Spurs 34 18 6 10 0 60
7. Man Utd 33 17 6 10 18 57
8. Southampton 34 13 9 12 5 48
9. Newcastle 34 14 4 16 -14 46
10. Stoke 34 11 10 13 -10 43

Breaking League News

Not the Best of Times?
West Ham : 16/04/2014 13:03:00
Livermore Interest
West Ham : 16/04/2014 13:02:00
Petrescu in Premier League Return?
Chelsea : 16/04/2014 12:57:00
Could Luke Shaw be off to United?
Chelsea : 16/04/2014 12:56:00
Could Man City lose Champions League spot?
Everton : 16/04/2014 11:00:00
PATHETIC - EARLY GOALS
Spurs : 16/04/2014 10:18:00
The Goodison factor
Everton : 16/04/2014 10:00:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM v Bayern (a)?
Suggested By:  Red Boy
De Gea 7%
Smalling 5%
Jones 5%
Vidic 5%
Evra 5%
Carrick 5%
Valencia 5%
Kagawa 58%
Fletcher 5%
Welbeck 0%
Rooney 0%
Hernandez 0%
Januzaj 0%