Vital Football

Latest Manchester United News

United Must Avoid Mistakes Of 2003

United Must Avoid Mistakes Of 2003

Manchester United have been crowned champions in 2007, four years after winning their last title. In 2003, I believe we committed great mistakes which must not be repeated.

The summer of 2003 had seen great changes at Manchester United who had just wrestled the title from Arsenal's hands. We sold two key players and bought some others who were quite simply not good enough to wear the shirt. Let's take a look at where it had gone wrong back then.

We sold David Beckham and Juan Sebastian Veron and did not replace them with suitable players.

One might argue that the latter has never been a great player for Manchester United and that Becks' relationship with Ferguson had deteriorated to a point where working together had been no longer possible. And they would be too damn right.

The problem is that both players had been better by a mile than their successors. In the case of Beckham, Ronaldo's turned out to be a talisman, the most valuable player of the club but in his first season he was no more than a one-trick showpony with little end product.

Veron will never be remembered as one of the greats and rightly so: he simply did not fit into our midfield that had been broken up for him. Still, he had the quality and experience to put together decent performances - and the same could not be said of Eric Djemba-Djemba or Kleberson who were meant to replace him.

Quite simply, the problem was that transition was not achieved gradually.

Instead that drastic steps were taken but we did not buy quality: Djemba-Djemba, Kleberson and the third misfit of the summer, David Bellion never had a future at Manchester United. The mistakes of that summer ensured that the next three years would be an uphill struggle while trying to plug some gaping holes.

I'd argue that all of Fergie's purchases in 2004, 2005 and 2006 were successful had it not been for injuries but the rebuilding process had been almost terminally undermined by the mistakes of that one summer.

Now we're in a similar position. The title has been secured and now the papers are talking about dropping the golden oldies, Giggs and Scholes and selling Heinze, Smith, Saha, Fletcher and a number of other players.

Our purchases so far are clearly superior to the flops of 2003. I firmly believe that Nani, Anderson and Hargreaves will go on to become excellent acquisitions - if, and only if, we retain the core of the squad that have won the title.

I had voiced my concerns earlier about Nani: I had feared he would tempt Ronaldo back to his old ways. I'm still sure the Portuguese youngster will need time to adapt to life at Old Trafford. That's why Ryan Giggs' role will still be vital - as a player and as a person whose experience is invaluable to youngsters.

The same could be said of Paul Scholes. He's had a mesmerising season and though I don't expect him to reach such heights again he's still got a lot to offer. He must be eased out gradually, just like Giggs. Throwing Anderson and Nani into the middle of things will not do wonders.

As for the other players: we've never had a big enough squad for the 2003/04 season and paid the price for it during a disastrous winter. So don't sell anyone who could play an important part next season. Sell players who did not do well last season and who are clearly not needed - Richardson, and it pains me to say, Eagles. Saha, Fletcher and Smith should be kept unless we get a quality striker - in that case, one of either Saha or Smith could leave if he's desperate to do so.

Heinze and Silvestre will be linked with moves away from Old Trafford but I think we should sell only one of them AND only if Pique or Evans are ready for a place in the first team. I think both of them are ready but it's not my job to decide.

Therefore, Fergie will have a very important task this summer: he must convince those who might fear for their place, most notably Heinze, Fletcher and Smith that we need a big squad to compete on all fronts as it has been proved the season just past. For the man who convinced Ronaldo to stay after last summer's World Cup, this task can't seem to difficult.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Monday June 4 2007
Time: 9:58AM


And those who I didn't mention in the article: O'Shea, Brown and Ole should be persuaded, too. I can't see the latter wanting to leave while O'Shea and Brown are good cover for Gary who's not getting younger and both can play centre-back, too.
04/06/2007 10:02:00
if we keep this squad together just selling a couple of players i think we can keep our title next season too.
04/06/2007 14:45:00
Not many United fans genuinely believed back in August that we could win the title. This summer will be different :-)
04/06/2007 14:51:00
couldnt agree more midolothian, this is the first season in some time that i geniunly think we will retin our title!
04/06/2007 15:09:00
...unless we sell half a dozen players...
04/06/2007 15:11:00
we shoulod sell richardson and silvestre but we should try to keep hold of heinze. Im sure this was just a bad season for him and with a full pre season training can back to his excellent best
04/06/2007 15:40:00
Exactly what I'm hoping for mattweeden. However, if we sell someone it's more likely to be Heinze, simply because more clubs would be interested in him than in Silvestre.
04/06/2007 15:41:00
evra or heinze?, who's in your opinion considered in the first team when both are fit - for me its evra
04/06/2007 16:25:00
evra for me too
04/06/2007 18:34:00
i say evra too but i still wouldnt like to sell heinze
04/06/2007 21:27:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Best of International Football News


Recent Manchester United Articles

United Lead the Chase for Ivory Coast International

But there is fierce competition!

Spurs Rivalling United for PSG Star

Manchester United`s hopes of signing Lucas Moura might be about to be dealt a blow.

Burnley v Manchester United - Fascinating Facts

This Saturday, Manchester United are at Turf Moor, taking on Burnley in a Premier League fixture

Burnley v Manchester United - Early Team-News

Last weekend, courtesy of results going their way, Manchester United closed the gap between themselves and Manchester City to twelve points.

Manchester United Archived Articles

Vital United articles from

Site Journalists

Red Boy
Editor email
Charlie Bacchus
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Burnley v Manchester United?
Suggested By: Red Boy
Burnley to Win!0%
Manchester United to Win!100%
A Draw!0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Manchester United Results (view all)

Manchester United Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

Vital Football Comment