Vital Football

Latest Manchester United News

Fergie: It Was A Penalty

Fergie: It Was A Penalty

Sir Alex rues fatigue and refereeing decisions after losing the FA Cup final to Chelsea.

To be honest, I could not muster the strength yesterday night to read post-match quotes. I did it today and one thing shocked me: Fergie's insistence on a penalty.

The boss felt that before Giggs' non-goal the Welsh Wizard had been fouled by Michael Essien.

'It was a penalty kick, ' said Sir Alex.

'Then the goalkeeper's spilled the ball behind the line. I think it will have been a difficult one for the linesman to call but the referee should be in a better position.

'I couldn't see the incident from where I was, there were players right in front of me, but I've seen it since (on TV) and it was a clear penalty kick. The referee must have been in a good position to see that. It's disappointing to see the replay, I must say.

'I think the pressure (Chelsea boss Jose) Mourinho put on the referee before the game has certainly worked and I'm (also) disappointed at that.'

I've watched the incident on tape and I must say I failed to spot any contact between Essien and Giggs so I still think that the correct decision would have been a free kick to Chelsea.

As for Mourinho putting pressure on the referee: it certainly worked but not in their favour. Quite simply, Steve Bennett blew his whistle whenever someone appeared to make physical contact with someone. It did not favour Chelsea or us: it simply contributed to make the game even tighter. I don't like Steve Bennett and my opinion of him did not improve but his decision meant no disadvantage for us.

'There was nothing between the two teams,' continued Fergie. ''Neither team deserved to win or lose to be honest. It`s just disappointing we have lost. 'The pitch was slow, that didn't help the match.

'From our point of view I think we were a bit tired in two or three positions which didn't help us. What the players have been through these last few months has been exceptional, I've got to give them credit for that. They just couldn`t cross the line today.'

I agree about the pitch and it's true that very little was between the two teams. However, speaking of fatigue would be OK if we played Arsenal but Chelsea played even more games this season and they even used some of their half-fit players in this final so fatigue should not be an excuse. We just could not cross the line, that's the truth.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Sunday May 20 2007
Time: 1:46PM


A fair summary. The trouble is with matches between these 2 teams (and probably the "top 4") is that it means so much more than the result of one match no matter how big. A United win yesterday and they would be rightfully lording it over Chelsea all close season. A Chelsea win and they got a bit of pride back, took just a bit of gloss of Uniteds title as everyone looks back to the last match. In these circumstances it was never likely to be a classic unless there was an early goal and the losing side had to go for it.
20/05/2007 15:26:00
its about time fergie had the ********* to "go at" these so called top teams.they can't live with us when we are "at it".complete and utter ****e yesterday and we got what we deserved.nothing!
20/05/2007 16:18:00
wow..a well balanced article. Thumbs up to u.
20/05/2007 16:49:00
64 games we played, we were out on our feet in extra time!
20/05/2007 17:41:00
Sums it up pretty well Zae, good read. Best of luck next season.
Blue is the colour
20/05/2007 20:43:00
I also fail to spot any contact with Essien and Giggs. Giggs himself also didn't notice any contact. Giggs just feels he ought to be allowed to plough his knees into the keepers head, knock him back a foot and a half and it count as a goal. Giggs is a great player, but he isn't Nat Lofthouse and this isn't the 50s. Well said here though.
21/05/2007 12:43:00
Good honest article mate, I cant understand Fergies comments myself.
21/05/2007 15:04:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Recent Manchester United Articles

United Face Fight to Hang on to Rashford?

The emergence of Marcus Rashford was a huge bonus for Manchester United.

United Linked with Bayern Munich Defender

But so are others!

Who Is The Premier League's Penalty Save King?

Another boring international break has hit this March, so if you've ever wondered who has saved the most penalties in Premier League history - wonder no more!

United`s Darmian Headed for Juventus

According to transfer speculation, appearing in the media, the end of the season could see Matteo Darmian leave Manchester United.

Manchester United Archived Articles

Vital United articles from

Site Journalists

Red Boy
Editor email
Charlie Bacchus
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Songsheets and Loudhailers- to improve the OT atmosphere?
Suggested By: Red Boy
Yes Please!100%
No Thanks!0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Manchester United Results (view all)

Manchester United Fixtures

Vital Football Comment