UK time is: 12:19:42
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

United - Is it the System?

A prominent former United player reckons it is!

Our poor, no shocking, start to the season whereby we`ve taken one point from the six available, in the Premier League, whilst also having seen our hopes of winning the Capital One Cup obliterated by League One MK Dons, has generated numerous column inches.

Everybody appears to be, after such a dominant pre-season, puzzled as to why Manchester United are struggling so badly.

Okay, perhaps there is disappointment in the air that, once again, we`re scrambling around for signings as the transfer window closure threatens and okay we`ve been troubled by injury, but is there a simpler explanation to be had?

Paul Scholes, who seems to have plenty to say for himself since retiring as a player, reckon sit is all down to the new system Louis Van Gaal has decided to employ. Scholes is of the opinion that is the change in tactics is the reason why we`ve become so porous defensively.

Is he correct or have you another reason you`d like to put up for debate?

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Red Boy Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday August 28 2014

Time: 7:47AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
It won't just be the system its probably not helping but it can't be solely to blame. We're just on the receiving end of a 5hitstorm combination of half arsed/useless players, a new system, a new regime and a boat load of cripples. Given time for the team to settle the injuries to subside and a few new faces we should be fine. Everyone seems to be forgetting that if we had the players we wouldn't be playing 352 we'd be probably playing 433.
Report Abuse
28/08/2014 08:51:00

Motors not wrong in saying it's not solely down to the formation. For me though during this tough spell of low confidence, fractured mentality and transition the last thing the players need is to have to re-learn their roles and positions in a new formation on top of it. No doubt Van Gaal will persist with the 3-5-2 and hopefully it proves fruitful but I just can't see it myself.

I know he said we didn't have the tools for a 4-3-3 and at the time it was a fair critique but now that we've got a world class winger i'm not buying it. You could have 2 at the back from Evans, Smalling, Jones, Rojo, Blackett or Keane. A right back from Rafael, Jones or Valencia. A left back from Shaw, Rojo or Young. 3 in midfield from Carrick, Fletcher, Fellaini, Herrera, Rooney, Di Maria. 2 wingers from Di Maria, Januzaj, Valencia, Young and then a forward of RVP, Rooney, Hernandez or Welbeck.
Report Abuse
28/08/2014 10:43:00

System or not, when your defence is of a mid table standard you are going to lose games that you shouldn't and right now our defence is poor. If we are playing 3 CBs you would imagine we would concede less and not lose games but we are, I can't see how switching to 2 CB's would help considering the options that we have available to us. Personally I do not like the 352 system, I'd prefer a 4231 (wide) but whatever system we play we will end up leaving out Rooney or Mata or Di Maria, we need defenders in strong physical ones who can lead from the back, like Vidic did until that happens we'll concede soft gaols and whatever advantage our forward players give us is mute when you have a shoddy defence. We have had a few bad injuries and we are still hamstrung by some absolutely crap players. Unlike the Moyes era I still feel confident that we have someone who can address the problems. I can see us switching to a 4231 (Narrow 3) with 3 players Di Maria, Rooney, Mata playing in behind RVP maybe given licence to roam out wide when needed.
Report Abuse
28/08/2014 11:10:00

Is not just that the defence is crap they have no cover we need a defensive midfielder. It isn't helping every time an opponent attacks they utterly bypass midfield straight onto an invariably out of position defence. Not being able to string two passes together doesn't help either.
Report Abuse
28/08/2014 11:54:00

I agree our def mid options are shockingly bad but it has been like that for a long time. Our defence shouldn't have much to do in a game against Swansea or Sunderland but when they are called upon they are utter crap.At the back we are lacking in confidence and leadership. Vidal is a priority, as is a strong centre back however the options we have left ourselves are very limiting, we've seen Mangala, Lovren and Benatia sold by their respective clubs and were we even sniffing around them?
Report Abuse
28/08/2014 15:19:00

I'm only here because of the Cleverley-to-Villa rumours, but I have to say, as an outsider with no axe to grind (apart from getting our arses handed to us twice a year for the past 20-odd years!) your main problem is definitely the defence and lack of a shield for them. Evans (and Jones, I would argue) are not good enough to base a title winning side upon, and although you've signed Rojo (now, where did I put that Work Permit??) and Luke Shaw (a real 'one for the FUTURE'), spunking near-on 60m on di Maria just doesn't make sense to me. He's a fine player, but surely more the 'cherry on top' type? If you can get William Carvalho (or Vidal maybe), and a decent centre-back to go with Rojo (Vlaar maybe?) then you might just get that show on the road. I hope so - we need as many strong teams as possible in the Premier League (and Europe), and United are far too big to stay away for long.
Report Abuse
28/08/2014 20:35:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester United Articles

Zaha Set For Permanent Palace Move! (Wednesday January 28 2015)

Fletcher Move Stalls! (Wednesday January 28 2015)

Rafael Could Be Back! (Wednesday January 28 2015)

A Nice Little Nice Earner (Tuesday January 27 2015)

United - Beware Real Cash Splash! (Tuesday January 27 2015)

Valdes Makes United Debut (Tuesday January 27 2015)

United on the TV (Monday January 26 2015)

Archived Manchester United Articles

List All Vital United Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Q.P.R. 0 - 2 Man Utd
Man Utd 0 - 1 Southampton
Stoke 1 - 1 Man Utd
Spurs 0 - 0 Man Utd
Man Utd 3 - 1 Newcastle
Aston Villa 1 - 1 Man Utd

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 22 16 4 2 32 52
2. Man City 22 14 5 3 23 47
3. Southampton 22 13 3 6 21 42
4. Man Utd 22 11 7 4 15 40
5. Arsenal 22 11 6 5 14 39
6. Spurs 22 11 4 7 2 37
7. West Ham 22 10 6 6 10 36

Breaking League News

Liverpool: FA Cup Games Live On TV
Liverpool : 29/01/2015 11:09:00
Wenger Highlights Gabriel's Qualities
Arsenal : 29/01/2015 10:32:00
Qatar hospitality was phenomenal
Everton : 29/01/2015 10:00:00
Ospina Enjoying Life At Arsenal
Arsenal : 29/01/2015 09:53:00
The Ox: Arsenal Are In a Good Place
Arsenal : 29/01/2015 09:34:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM v Cambridge (a) FA Cup
Suggested By:  Red Boy
De Gea 20%
Valencia 5%
Joness 1%
Rojo 16%
Blind 0%
Carrick 0%
Januzaj 43%
Fellaini 5%
Di Maria 3%
Wilson 0%
Falcao 3%
Herrera 1%
Van Persie 0%
Shaw 3%