Vital Football

Latest Manchester United News

Richardson's United Career Is Over?

Richardson's United Career Is Over?

I must admit I am one of Kieran Richardson's greatest fans. He impressed me during his early days here and he was instrumental in keeping West Bromwich in the Premier League in 2005. His last season was decent, his performance and his goal against Charlton made me feel he could even make it here. His inconsistency did not worry me unduly, it could be attributed to his age.

However, it seems he failed. It maybe too early to tell but think about the Wigan game. Ronaldo and Park out, and Giggs just back after a hamstring injury so I expected Richardson to start as he was the only fit winger. But Fergie who was ready to play him against Spurs and Reading opted for two strikers, Rooney and Solskjaer to play on the wings - it must be a bad omen for Richardson. His two games as a starter were lamentable: he looked bemused and completely out of his depth. Could not beat a man to save his life, his passing was awful and against Reading he failed to hit the ball when he should have scored.

I hope it's just a spell of bad form. But I fear for him: perhaps he's simply not up to the scratch. I talked to some fans who suggested we should try him in the middle because he could be a player of the Scholes' type. I think that cannot be considered as a serious idea. Richardson will never have the vision and passing skills that Ginger Prince have and he's a physical lightweight.

He's quick, but not very fast. He has a good shot, he can cross so I think he can be a decent, useful member of a mid-table team. But he does not seem to be United material.

Patrice Evra, meanwhile, is going the other way. A lot of United fans were perplexed (myself included) when Fergie signed him in the winter and his first few games suggested he would be a flop. However, he's seriously impressed me since the start of this season. The little Frenchman started to apply himself in the left-back's position really well, his tackling and attacking work improved a lot, he's steadily maturing into the team. He seems wonderfully assured on the ball so I think we can count on him whenever Heinze whom I still consider to be our first-choice left-back is absent.

He's definitely better than Silvestre whom I like but his place in the squad can be questioned. In central defence we have Brown, Vidic, Ferdinand and O'Shea. The latter can play at left-back where we have Heinze and Evra. Johnny Evans and Pique is coming back next year so there's no place for poor, injured Silvestre who can easily find himself out of Old Trafford come next August.


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Zae
Date:Tuesday October 17 2006
Time: 4:52PM

Comments

0
If you leaves Man U someone will be getting a good little player!
Cravens
18/10/2006 07:03:00
0
did ok for you last night though in the end eh ? do not think he will leave you to be honest
dazednconfuzed
18/10/2006 10:10:00
0
To be honest he made no impact yesterday. His shot was absolutely mediocre and I still wonder how it went in. He is yet to convince me he can raise his game in the near future.
midlothian99
18/10/2006 14:59:00
0
he will stay if fergy sells him i think mun u should sell fergy ?
marshinrover
18/10/2006 16:31:00
0
I do not think Fergie wants to sell him but Richardson needs to improve or he simply won't get into the team! I like him very much but fear for him.
midlothian99
18/10/2006 17:48:00
0
He'll get goals for you, needs games though! Talented player!!!!
BaldyYid
20/10/2006 13:43:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester United Articles

Three More Premier League Clubs Interested in Smalling

Yesterday following speculation in the media, we ran an article covering West Bromwich Albion`s interest in Chris Smalling.

Martial Shows What He Can Do

As he rips the Real Madrid defence to shreds.

Bailly Given Further Two Game Ban by UEFA

Back in April, when Manchester United beat Celta Vigo to reach the Europa League Final, against Ajax, Eric Bailly received a red-card after a brawl broke-out.

West Brom Preparing Bid for Manchester United Defender

Speculation has raised its head again suggesting that one of Manchester United`s central defenders could be leaving during this transfer window.

Archived Vital United Articles

Vital United articles from

Site Journalists

Red Boy
Editor email
Profile
Charlie Bacchus
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

How Many Goals Will Lukaku Score for United this season?
Suggested By: Red Boy
5 - 10!5%
11 - 15!3%
16 - 20!11%
20 +81%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Manchester United Results (view all)

Manchester United Fixtures (view all)

Aug 7 2017 12:00AM : Leicester City (a)
Community Shield

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.TBABA204
2.ambler3
3.alex682
4.balomoney2
5.Antlow2
6.Derichie_me1
7.wolphragm1
8.tundeowo1
9.Mohrino1
10.ForeverUnited1
Write for Vital Football