Vital Football

Latest Manchester United News

Did Man Utd Pay Too Much?

Did Man Utd Pay Too Much?

Vital Manchester United asked, in last weeks poll, if Manchester United were mugs to pay £18million (including add ons) for Michael Carrick?

We split it between United and Spurs fans.

23% (Spurs fans), yes you were and only 1% voted for the (Spurs fan) no, that was about right.

37% (Man Utd fans) also said we paid too much and 8% (Man Utd fans) said the fee was about right.

So, shocking as it might sound, the majority agree with our London friends!

4% said £18 million is too much for any player and 27% are sitting on the fence and will decide at the end of the season.

Our latest poll asks if Rooney is right to threaten to strike over his ban.


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Cantona
Date:Monday August 21 2006
Time: 6:04PM

Comments

0
Utter Rubbish - Chelsea have just spent £8 - 9 million on Boulahrouz. Carrick is twice the player and will play a much more important and pinacle role in the squad then a wing back. How much would you pay to see Steven Gerrard at Trafford Park? 40? Carrick is much more than half the player SG is. Well done Fergey for making a solid purchase.
Cpt. Mainwaring
21/08/2006 18:27:00
0

Carrick is much more than half the player SG is.
When we're done laughing, we'll send you the award for the best carrick one liner in the mail.
Which half by the way? He doesn't tackle, or run, or score, or lead the team, and his work rate isn't envious. He can pass, but so can Xabi Alonso, and MUCH better than him (Xabi is also younger, scores more, better leader, more vision and has goood defensive play). Xabi cost 10 million quid, and is an international fixture in Spain's midfield. Carrick is an England substitute on a good day.
That's not to say Carrick is a bad player, or that he's not a good addition to the Utd. midfield... but 18 mill? He can be the next Rio or the next Veron.
no13
21/08/2006 19:18:00
0
no13 is right, for a centre midfielder he aint up to much, cant tackle, isnt gonna control a game and from what ive heard youd swear he was a footballing visionary, a one man, defence splitting, passing machine, spurs(zokora),arsenal(rosicky),chelsea(ballack) have all signed better players who cost less to add to their already good midfield options whereas we got done outta 18 million for a average player, give me xabi alonso or even scott parker any day instead of carrick
Kanchelskis
21/08/2006 19:39:00
0
i agree he will be a good buy
carrickisours
21/08/2006 21:15:00
0
Number 13 don't forget the free kicks with fiendish power and pin point accuracy but to give him dues not a bad thrower of the ball.
MarteenGottspennes
22/08/2006 01:36:00
0
cant tackle r u crazy look back to the arsenal game last season oh there was brilliant tackles
carrickisours
22/08/2006 21:10:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester United Articles

The Manchester United Injury Table Updated

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Manchester United and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

United Transfer Target Headed to London?

Somebody who has been mentioned in despatches as a possible / probable transfer target for Manchester United this summer, could be bound for England but not Manchester.

Juventus Interested in Buying Fellaini

Lurking in the pages of a popular tabloid publication is the insinuation that a Manchester United midfielder is a transfer target for a top Italian club.

Transfer Windows To End Early?

The Premier League and the EFL will both be seeking thoughts from member clubs on whether or not to close the summer transfer window before the season kicks off in coming years.

Archived Vital United Articles

Vital United articles from

Site Journalists

Red Boy
Editor email
Profile
Charlie Bacchus
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Swansea v Manchester United?
Suggested By: Red Boy
Home Win!0%
Away Win!0%
Draw!0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Manchester United Results (view all)

Manchester United Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.emmillin4
2.Amb.Whoknows4
3.ambler3
4.ForeverUnited2
5.mad_manu1
6.Baklay371
Vital Football Comment