Vital Football

Latest Manchester United News

Lucky City Survive Second Half Battering

Lucky City Survive Second Half Battering

Oh god, I hoped it would not come to pass but now everything will be full of giddy and cocky City fans for a week after their victory tonight. However, it will be obvious to anyone who saw the game that United are clear favourites to progress.

Fergie fielded a very strong line-up, with Carrick, Fletcher and Anderson in a midfield three supporting an attacking trio of Valencia, Rooney and Giggs. And this worked quite well from the beginning: United were comfortable in possession and though we did not create much, we were the more positive team.

We were rewarded with a deserved goal with 20 minutes gone: Evra whipped over a diagonal ball to Valencia who crossed for Rooney. His close-range effort was saved by Given but Giggs was on hand to convert the rebound.

United fans outsang their home counterparts even before the goal but after it, the silence was almost deafening but for a corner of the stadium where the visiting fans were gleefully singing the best of their repertoire.

Inexplicably, United lost some of their composure on the ball after the goal and allowed City more time and space but the hosts' were very poor and could not create anything at all, even against a makeshift backline including Brown, Evans and Rafael.

However, the latter made a mistake in the closing stages of the first half which was compounded by Mike Dean's extreme error: Rafael clearly let go of Bellamy's shirt before the area but the referee awarded a penalty which the otherwise very ineffective Tevez converted and then proceeded to do some really childish celebrations. Spiteful petulant prat, he is.

The second half started in a scrappy fashion: City could have scored early on as our defence displayed their ridiculous inability to deal with any set-piece that came across while Rooney and Giggs both could and should have restored United's advantage but they spurned their opportunities.

And they soon regretted it after another corner caused mayhem in the United box, Anderson, Evans, Rafael, Brown and co. running around without a clue, allowing Tevez to head it in from close range and proceed to do some even more childish and petulant celebration.

But unlike many other occasions on which we fell behind, we had a response this time. Fergie sent on Michael Owen for Anderson and United proceeded to batter City for the last 20 minutes of the tie. Given produced three great saves from Rooney alone; Owen had a shot cleared off the line; substitute Diouf headed wide with the goal gaping; Valencia fired wide of an empty net from two yards out...

So, in the end, plucky little City held on to a famous win in their cup final - but there is little evidence to suggest that United won't take them apart at Old Trafford. If we play like we did tonight, especially in the last 20 minutes then it should be no problem. Foster won't be in goal this time so everything's there for us to reach a second consecutive Carling Cup final.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Tuesday January 19 2010
Time: 11:12PM


If only your owners were as good with the propaganda as this writer then they might actually convince the world that you have some money in the bank! And our cup final? In future years we will be known as your cup final as the sinking ship that is United has hit the iceberg and the water is beginning to pour in.
19/01/2010 23:21:00
i have seen the replay for the so called penalty....i have never seen a ref award a penalty for that in all the matches i have watched.... one thing i don't get is why everyone thinks the advantage is with city....claiming they pretty much bagged their spot in the final....we got the away goal(with the supposedly weakened team) as well as unfair refereeing ...but i won't complain much about refs cuz i guess it could happen(i.e. chelsea-barca) but i think we have a good advantage with the away goal, and hopefully for the second leg we would have a decent back four who are fit and ready..i think we will make it thru to the final
19/01/2010 23:37:00
"i have never seen a ref award a penalty for that in all the matches i have watched" - Watch a replay of Man City vs Everton from last week then. You got an away goal, but we got the win :D
19/01/2010 23:45:00
You've never seen a penalty for that incident before??? Did you not watch Everton v City last Saturday?
19/01/2010 23:45:00
Absolutely eighthsin, spot on!
20/01/2010 00:01:00
City are My God, 'away goal' counts for ***** in the 'Carling' League Cup!! Sounds like 1969 to m e ....
20/01/2010 00:03:00
It was good to see us step up a gear when we went 2-1 down. Was really disappointed for Mame when he missed that header. I really want to see more of him as I think even if he turns out to be the worst finisher in the world his physical presence and pace would open up the game for rooney who is wasted as the lone striker. But still, based on the way the two sides played I'd say its 50/50.
20/01/2010 00:34:00
3-0 at Old Toilet. Fergie sign him up.
taggarts nose
20/01/2010 00:34:00
no why would u assume i will watch everton vs city...not a city fan...never will...i just thought it was one of the softest calls ever given....but again i did stress i won't complain about refereeing cuz i always remember what happened to chelsea against barca and i tell myself...hey i guess it could happen...let it go
20/01/2010 01:14:00
Tevez's celebration was a direct response to Gary Neville's stupidity and Man Utd fans' stupidity to boo him last time. It was simply just payback for disrespect received. I don't see anything wrong with it.
20/01/2010 01:32:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester United Articles

United Target Happy Where He Is Claim

Continuing, as you do, on defensive matters, the media have reported that Manchester United have expressed an interest in a centre-back currently playing in Serie A.

United Linked to Arsenal Defender

But it could be a forlorn chase for the full-back!

Martial`s Old Trafford Future Questioned

This summer, we`re fully expecting there to be some movement on the player front at Old Trafford.

Sanchez Likened to Di Maria?

As we struggle to keep the journalistic momentum during yet another international break, the form of one player appears to be generating some unwanted column inches.

Manchester United Archived Articles

Vital United articles from

Site Journalists

Red Boy
Editor email
Charlie Bacchus
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

MOTM v Brighton (FA Cup)?
Suggested By: Red Boy
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Manchester United Results (view all)

Manchester United Fixtures

The Vital Football Members League