UK time is: 20:17:00
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Martin Lipton Is Officially The ABU-In-Chief Now

It seems that hating Manchester United actually gives you an excuse not to bother about the most basic rules of journalism, like those of objectivity and proper research. At least that was the case with Oliver Holt whose articles in the Mirror always contained ill-informed snipings at Fergie and he usually delivered withering assessment of both the boss and the team.

He's mellowed recently, toning down his ABUism but the Mirror has the perfect replacement in Martin Lipton, an experienced writer who seems to be totally blinded by hatred of all things United.

Writing about Rafa Benitez, he could not resist taking a few swings at Manchester United, no matter how unjustified and untruthful they certainly are. Here are a few extracts from the 'article'.

'What Benitez said was, in the main, not only justified but also accurate.

Fergie does get away with more than any other manager. Always has, always will. Referees, the Premier League, the FA - let alone the media - are terrified by him...'


And yet Sir Alex Ferguson is the only one who received a touchline ban last season. As for the media: I can't remember anyone calling for a five-match ban for Benitez after he questioned the officials' experience after their game at Spurs. When Fergie dared to raise a similar question - he focused on fitness, not experience - he was crucified.

'Even then, as Benitez and his players ruefully know, it might have changed after they thumped United at Old Trafford, only for the gods - and referees - to come to Fergie's aid: the extra minutes against Aston Villa which allowed Federico Macheda to emerge from nowhere and, most infamously, Howard Webb's shocker against Spurs that was the pivotal moment of the entire campaign.'

If you watch any video of Macheda's goal - which Lipton certainly did not do - you will see the ball landing in the net at 92:04. Surely even the most fervent ABU can't seriously believe that a game poised at 2-2 should not have two minutes of time added on? Yes, the ref added five minutes - but in reality that meant that Villa had time to find an equaliser which fortunately they did not.

Howard Webb's shocker that was the pivotal moment. Oh yes, this is my favourite and this is something that Lipton brings up very often. To put things into perspective: United were TWO DOWN when Webb awarded a penalty which, at first, looked stonewall. Ronaldo put that away but we were still 2-1 down with 35 minutes to go. Is it Howard Webb's fault that Spurs collapsed?

Of course not - but it's his fault that they took a two-goal lead. Had he sent Wilson Palacios off for a vicious challenge on Ronaldo in the eighth minute, the game could have turned out very differently. Here's the link to the Palacios challenge for those of you who can't remember it: http://img402.imageshack.us/img402/9347/palacios.gif

It's obviously worthy of a straight red and I must say Spurs were lucky: instead of playing more than 80 minutes with only ten men on the field, they merely had to put up with a dubious penalty when they were 2-0 ahead. That they could not hold on to their lead is hardly Howard Webb's fault: he gave them the chance to compete by not sending Palacios off for a disgraceful attempt to maim Ronaldo.

Oh, and supposedly United fan Mike Riley's decision to show the red card to Lampard for a fair tackle at Anfield is somehow omitted from Lipton's article. Wasn't that a pivotal moment? It allowed Liverpool to do their double over Chelsea and cling on to United's tail. With Webb gifting Spurs the chance to compete at Old Trafford, the refs actually nearly presented Liverpool with the title. And we haven't even mentioned the unjustified red cards of Adebayor and Valencia...

So, we have our new ABU-in-Chief. We can look forward to more of the same from Lipton as it's unlikely that he'll allow facts (real ones, not Benitez-type facts) to get in the way of a good United-bashing.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Zae Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday October 21 2009

Time: 12:32PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Martin Lipton doesn't like City either and by the way doesn't Oliver Holt watch United regularly in addition to Stockport County?
Kevinho
Report Abuse
21/10/2009 12:43:00

What he said was correct in terms of him getting away with more than any other manager. He is a persistent offender and is only charged for a fraction of them. Wait till he retires and can't threaten expulsion from Old Trafford. Watch how he is written about then. Most of the media are spineless when it comes to him, hence his rampant hypocrisy isn't highlighted further for fear of being banished.
KB1
Report Abuse
21/10/2009 18:35:00

Thank god KB1 isn't a jouranlist, what a narrow minded view in light of this article. Give us some examples then of persistent offending he gets away with compared to other managers.
NotoriousRedDevil
Report Abuse
21/10/2009 20:18:00

Do you want examples of screaming into the face of officials regularly without censure? Possibly we could then look at the treatment afforded the Arsenal manager when he kicked a water bottle. Why is it that only Utd fans don't see this part of him when everyone else does. Yet I am narrow minded?
KB1
Report Abuse
22/10/2009 14:11:00

No don't avoid what I said. Examples of when Sir Alex Ferguson has got away with stuff. You haven't got any examples so once again unfounded criticism from yourself by reading the tabloids.
NotoriousRedDevil
Report Abuse
22/10/2009 18:11:00

I didn't avoid what you said. You want a concrete example? Portsmouth in the Cup. What was his punishment there?
KB1
Report Abuse
23/10/2009 11:17:00

Wow you had a whole 2 days & go back a whole 2 years for that. I though Fergie got away with stuff all the time. He got warned about his conduct like Rafa at Spurs. The next time he did it he got actually got a touchline ban. Try again.
NotoriousRedDevil
Report Abuse
23/10/2009 13:05:00

A whole two days? I replied yesterday. If you are seriously stating that Ferguson doesn't intimidate, harass and berate referees then I am giving your intelligence more credence than than I should (which wasn't much originally to be fair). Besides, you asked for an instance and I gave you one. Ergo, I was correct.
KB1
Report Abuse
23/10/2009 13:54:00

Council house boy giving my intelligence more credit than he should. Now I have heard it all. LOL Pot calling kettle black. Your manager is hilarious he's now saying silveware isn't important!
NotoriousRedDevil
Report Abuse
23/10/2009 14:49:00

I don't live in a council house. Besides, don't you look longingly at them from your mum's crack den?
KB1
Report Abuse
23/10/2009 16:11:00

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester United Articles

A Small Tactical Change? (Wednesday March 4 2015)

On Schedule Dutch Star Declares (Wednesday March 4 2015)

Winning Ugly? (Tuesday March 3 2015)

Van Gaal Wants Long United Stay (Monday March 2 2015)

Archived Manchester United Articles

List All Vital United Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. TheFamousNo7 12
2. MotorMad 10
3. Kanchelskis 5

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 26 18 6 2 34 60
2. Man City 27 16 7 4 30 55
3. Arsenal 27 15 6 6 22 51
4. Man Utd 27 14 8 5 20 50
5. Southampton 28 15 4 9 19 49
6. Liverpool 27 14 6 7 10 48
7. Spurs 26 13 5 8 5 44

Breaking League News

Petrov On Sherwood & VP Return?
Aston Villa : 04/03/2015 19:12:01
Newcastle Utd v Manchester United - Team Line-Ups
Newcastle : 04/03/2015 19:10:01
Team Line-Ups - Manchester City v Leicester City
Leicester City : 04/03/2015 19:07:01
Liverpool: LFC vs. Burnley Team News
Liverpool : 04/03/2015 19:07:00
Manchester City v Leicester City - Team Line-Ups
Man City : 04/03/2015 19:07:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Newcastle v Manchester United?
Suggested By:  Red Boy
Home Win! 13%
Away Win! 87%
Score Draw! 0%
0-0 0%