Manchester United - United Lost The Midfield Battle
UK time is: 23:42:44
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

United Lost The Midfield Battle

Often the reasons of defeat are hard to find. Bad luck can play a part, individual mistakes, too and bad tactics can be disastrous as well. This time, however, there's not a great deal of investigation required: United lost the Champions League final because Barcelona easily won the midfield battle which proved crucial.

Why could they do so? Well, first I must repeat myself: Xavi and Iniesta are the best midfielders in the world right now. They have fantastic quality and on their day are unstoppable. How do you stop them? You need two energetic, quick tacklers and a third midfielder to tie up the loose ends.

Chelsea's midfield was physical enough in the second leg of the semi-final but could barely get out of their own half because it wasn't balanced enough. United's midfield yesterday was neither physical nor balanced enough. And it is easy to see why.

Carrick is a fine player - if he's allowed to dictate the game from deep, if he's got the time to read the patterns and make timely interceptions. In order to do that against such a strong team like Barcelona he would have needed another pair of legs in front of him, doing the dirty work.

Anderson tried but he rarely knew which way to turn as one of Xavi, Iniesta or Busquets was always available. Why? Because our third midfielder, Ryan Giggs, played too far ahead and he tracked back way too rarely. And Carrick, well, it would have been unreasonable to expect him to follow either Xavi or Iniesta everywhere as they are both much quicker than him.

So, my conclusion is predictable: what we desperately missed was either Hargreaves or Fletcher. I'm not saying we would have won the game with them - but we would have offered a sterner resistance, would have given a better account of ourselves.

Of course, all of this is that wonderful thing, hindsight. I was all for starting Ryan Giggs and still can't think of a better midfield in the absence of the aforementioned players. What is slightly baffling for me, though, is that why was Giggs positioned so far ahead? He was effectively a second striker behind Ronaldo for much of the game so it wasn't really 4-3-3, more like a 4-2-3-1. But for the latter formation, either Tevez or Berbatov would have been better (possibly).

And even so, it could have worked. Oh yes. Barcelona were really nervous in the opening minutes and we came out of the blocks flying. Valdes could not hold Ronaldo's free-kick and if only Park had been that little bit quicker to react... And a few minutes later, Ronaldo had a chance from inside the box but his shot just eluded the far corner.

Had we taken the lead it would have been a vastly different game and we had the chances to do so. But when Barcelona first crossed the halfway line Iniesta brutally exposed the limitations of our midfield: Carrick and Anderson were waiting for each other, neither attempted to tackle him so he had time and space to pick out a pass to Samuel Eto'o who embarassed Vidic (really, why he couldn't keep him on the outside? That would have been harmless) and scored.

Our mental collapse afterwards had a simple reason: we were set up to counter-attack and that was impossible with these lightning-quick front players pressing us all the time. Our unbalanced midfield wasn't allowed time on the ball and they aggravated the problem by being in a hurry even on the rare occasions when we had the chance to bring the ball out of defence and do some nice build-up play.

I think it was somewhat of a tactical decision: Fergie knew that in the absence of the tacklers we have we cannot pass ourselves through the midfield so he urged the troops to get the ball quickly to the front line to test Barcelona's supposedly weak defence. But these long ball were desperately inaccurate and rarely found their target.

And there's another thing, too. Barcelona sacrificed much of their attacking threat in order to ensure their defending remains disciplined and focused. Their midfield players closed down even the tiniest bit of spaces and even Eto'o and Henry tracked back on occasions. They didn't have as much possession as usually, only 52% but they defended better than any time I've ever seen them. They were constantly threatening in attack, of course but their safety-first approach was clear - and very efficient.

They deserved to win. It wasn't a 'battering', as Oliver Holt put it in the Mirror, barely concealing his delight and we weren't 'outclassed': quite simply we lost to a team which was in better form and had a better line-up on the night. Their midfield ensured they did not feel the absence of their defenders and that we had reasons to lament the suspension of Fletcher and the injury of Hargreaves. End of.

For the very latest Premier League odds

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Zae Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday May 28 2009

Time: 1:04PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Zae,my friend,I totally agree about the midfield situation but what caught my eye was the end of your article.I was thinking of the same thing but its normal,the media all around the world is the same.First they hype u up and they expect u to just win,losing is not an option and when u lose the same media will crucify u in a way that there has to be changes,may be the manager should step down,etc.It seems as if we have to pay the price for doing so well.
Report Abuse
28/05/2009 17:00:00

it was men against boys...what you needed was a manu loving ref. who would let your team get away with kicking and bullying the skillful passing team out of the game,and give you soft freekicks in dangerous areas...but alas this is not the premiership
fran merida
Report Abuse
28/05/2009 17:59:00

Chelsea's physicality certainly helped them in midfield against Barca, but more credit should be given to their defending. In the first leg they parked the bus. In the second they were forced to go forward more, and in all fairness they thwarted everything Barca had--save for the last miracle goal at the very end, when I think Chelsea was so exhausted they lost concentration. Your midfield let you down but so did your defense.
Report Abuse
29/05/2009 03:34:00

Carrick and co are alright against teams lower down in the prem but our midfield was exposed for what it is in Rome. The return of Hargreaves will give us half of what we need if we are going to compete at the very top next season, especially if pool and Chelsea invest over the summer break. We need a proven midfielder who will be hard to come by; strength in depth is one thing but we need big players for big games and our midfield isn’t up to it as it stands.
Report Abuse
29/05/2009 08:27:00

Police have confirmed that they have arrested a 27 year old Manchester man on suspicion of fraud. The man named as Michael Carrick is believed to have being at the centre of an £18m scam. The man charged has been masquerading as a top class international centre midfielder for 3 years. Italian authorities have handed overwhelming evidence of the fraud to English police including video footage of his inability to retain the ball, hit long range forward passes and poor defending.
Report Abuse
29/05/2009 11:09:00

That's a little harsh, Gleeson! Although to be fair it looked as if Carrick had never seen a football against Barcelona. I think he cracked under the pressure.
Report Abuse
29/05/2009 12:36:00

Manc fans need to take off those rose tinted glasses for once , you`re fans are well known 4 your bias distorted opinion of your team.....Man Utd couldnt even touch the ball 4 long periods and were chasing shadows...the whole world witnessed your team get battered...whether u Mancs accept it or not..the whole world saw it ....and the whole world laughed at you.......
I Bling Red
Report Abuse
29/05/2009 21:59:00

Lol Gleeson! But Carrick is their best midfeilder - apart from are really really missing him! I rate him, and a lot higher than Ji Sung Park and Anderson. Fletcher has had a good season, but you'll never have the mid we have of Lamps, Ballack and Essien!
Report Abuse
29/05/2009 23:46:00

Mr Feguson and Manchester united...Fact - premier champions 2009 (for the 3rd time running). Fact - club world champions 2009. Fact - carling cup 2009. Mr benitez and liverpool 2009. Fact - NOTHING!
Report Abuse
30/05/2009 22:24:00

...I agree sky, but we won the FA Cup yesterday! :)
Report Abuse
31/05/2009 13:15:00

basicly, you havn't replaced scholes!
Report Abuse
31/05/2009 18:18:00

haigh_for_7: well done, you deserved the win. It should be an interesting season again in 2009/2010
Report Abuse
31/05/2009 23:08:00

Report Abuse
01/06/2009 07:03:00

Report Abuse
01/06/2009 07:04:00

ha ha skylab - only Chelsea won ANYTHING out of the Premier League teams. no room to criticise. defeat to Barca was no shame, despite not performing at all.
Man utd champions
Report Abuse
02/06/2009 11:50:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester United Articles

United - Podcast Mania (Tuesday December 1 2015)

Is He or Isn`t He Happy? (Tuesday December 1 2015)

Neville Surviving Turmoil in Spain (Tuesday December 1 2015)

Listen to Your Mother! (Tuesday December 1 2015)

Groundhog Day (Tuesday December 1 2015)

Strange But True - Leicester (a) (Monday November 30 2015)

Leicester City 1 Manchester United 1 (Monday November 30 2015)

Leicester (a) - Van Gaal Speaks (Sunday November 29 2015)

AUDIO: van Gaal: We dominated (Sunday November 29 2015)

Archived Manchester United Articles

List All Vital United Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Man City 14 9 2 3 +16 29
2. Leicester City 14 8 5 1 +8 29
3. Man Utd 14 8 4 2 +10 28
4. Arsenal 14 8 3 3 +12 27
5. Spurs 14 6 7 1 +13 25
6. Liverpool 14 6 5 3 +3 23
7. Crystal Palace 14 7 1 6 +5 22

Manchester United Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Professional Stoke ease past Sheff Wed into League Cup Semi
» Stoke : 01/12/2015 23:33:01
» Stoke : 01/12/2015 23:12:00
» Everton : 01/12/2015 22:00:00
» Man City : 01/12/2015 21:33:00
Koeman On Evenly Matched Liverpool
» Southampton : 01/12/2015 20:35:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM v Leicester City
Suggested By:  Red Boy
De Gea 40%
McNair 0%
Smalling 7%
Blind 0%
Darmian 0%
Carrick 0%
Schweinsteiger 46%
Mata 0%
Martial 0%
Rooney 0%
Yong 7%
Depay 0%