Vital Football

Latest Manchester United News

United v Portsmouth - Player Ratings!

United v Portsmouth - Player Ratings!

Edwin van der Sar: He will get a mark for saving one penalty. Otherwise he had simply nothing to do, Pompey simply did not attack. 6

Gary Neville: The captain looked much, much better than against Juventus; it looks like he's improving steadily with every game. Now he's ready for the new season. 7

Rio Ferdinand: Had Crouch and Defoe in his pocket. An easy afternoon for the centre-back. 7

Nemanja Vidic: Troubled by neither Crouch nor Defoe, he did his job flawlessly. 7

Patrice Evra: Job tried and tried to get the better of him but Evra kept tackling him with embarassing ease. Had plenty of opportunity to join the attacks and he did that with relish. 7

Darren Fletcher: The Scottish midfielder, despite my lack of belief in him, was excellent on the right and would merit a higher mark had he managed to put away one of his chances. Used his pace and energy to great effect. 7

Paul Scholes: Did a solid job against Portsmouth's muscle men. Should have pulled the strings more effectively though, should have taken more risks. 6

John O'Shea: A rare occurence: he did well as a defensive midfielder. Effective with his tackling, his passing was a bit suspect. 6

Luis Nani: He must be told to forget about the referee as he wastes too much time arguing. A threat to any defence but his skills must be honed and refined before he could develop into a really dangerous attacker. 6

Ryan Giggs: One of his better games but too often he made the wrong decision in the final third of the pitch. 6

Carlos Tevez: He was everywhere as usual and his skills caused serious problems for Portsmouth. His dipping shot in the second half was brilliant, I still can't believe James actually saved it. 7

Wes Brown: Replaced Neville but made no impact.

Michael Carrick: Brought on for O'Shea and delivered a few fine passes and converted his penalty. 6

Frazier Campbell: His pace and aggressivity is impressive, just as impressive as the way he created himself a brilliant chance not long after his introduction. Shame he missed it. 7

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Sunday August 10 2008
Time: 7:21PM


Campbell 7? cmon!!, he was good but apart from the chance you mentioned he didnt do much else, he was a 6 at most
10/08/2008 19:37:00
a little biased are we not?
10/08/2008 20:37:00
I think nani deserves higher then a 6 surely.
10/08/2008 21:18:00
Wow merlin you sure your not a closet United fan?
10/08/2008 21:41:00
I think Merlin is more of a realistit!
11/08/2008 07:31:00
Evra made Job look silly, question is, who was he?
11/08/2008 07:42:00
i seen the game and man td deserved they're win but some of the ratings are out!!!
steve bhoy
11/08/2008 13:00:00
Tevez, was brilliant, van der Sar had nothing to do, but was good for penalties.
Man utd champions
11/08/2008 18:41:00
I know they're not much, but that's the second trophy we've won, and the season hasn't even started yet!!!!
Man utd champions
11/08/2008 18:42:00
Oh, and though it was a good performance, our attack looked worrying. We had plenty of chances but failed to take them (admittedly David James was in good form) and for me, Wayne Rooney can't return fast enough, as well as another striker coming in...
Man utd champions
11/08/2008 18:44:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester United Articles

United Target Happy Where He Is Claim

Continuing, as you do, on defensive matters, the media have reported that Manchester United have expressed an interest in a centre-back currently playing in Serie A.

United Linked to Arsenal Defender

But it could be a forlorn chase for the full-back!

Martial`s Old Trafford Future Questioned

This summer, we`re fully expecting there to be some movement on the player front at Old Trafford.

Sanchez Likened to Di Maria?

As we struggle to keep the journalistic momentum during yet another international break, the form of one player appears to be generating some unwanted column inches.

Manchester United Archived Articles

Vital United articles from

Site Journalists

Red Boy
Editor email
Charlie Bacchus
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

MOTM v Brighton (FA Cup)?
Suggested By: Red Boy
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Manchester United Results (view all)

Manchester United Fixtures

Write for Vital Football