Vital Football

Latest Manchester United News

Carrick Not Concerned By Criticism - He's Right

Carrick Not Concerned By Criticism - He's Right

There are many amazing things in football. Brazil 1970; the fact that very few women can ever understand the offside rule; that people actually believe Liverpool are going to win the title under Benitez.

But for me, none more amazing at the moment than that Michael Carrick still has to answer to doubters who are not convinced by two seasons' worth of solid, reliable displays which played a huge part in United's success.

He of course came with a huge price tag and got the No. 16 shirt which was bound to add to the media's expectation - and unfortunately, many United fans jumped on to the Carrick-slagging bandwagon.

'I didn't feel any weight of expectation,' Carrick insisted to Setanta. 'People were talking about it, but it is only a shirt and doesn't make too much difference.

'You've got to go out there and play your games so it didn't really make too much difference to me.

The argument most often brought forth was that he's not a midfield enforcer in the mould of Keane, he can't be expected to run from box-to-box, tackling everyone in sight and leading the team as Roy did. It was said he was only a silky passer with good intelligence on the field and not a proper hardman.

And what happened? Carrick provided silky passing and timely interceptions, exactly what could be expected of him and he did this at a very high standard. Yet some regarded this as a disappointment, despite that fact that his style fitted into United's football which brought us a league title in his first season.

True, I also criticised him at the autumn of 2007 - he simply wasn't performing up to the standards he had set for himself. But in the second half of the season he regained his form and produced some absolutely brilliant displays.

He added a Champions League title to his collection as well, converting his penalty in the shootout - and he's still got to face journalists who are questioning him about alleged doubters. What does he need to do? Turn into Roy Keane?

Everyone knew from the start that he's not Roy Keane so why blame him for it? He's a different character and a different player with a different style - but so far, the same success.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Thursday July 3 2008
Time: 9:05PM


Think there are plenty of teams across Europe that would love to have the lad.
03/07/2008 21:44:00
think hes agood player and he should be able to handle criticism every player has been criticised even th best
03/07/2008 23:02:00
Even me, and I don't play football.
04/07/2008 09:01:00
agree jamie, i think hes a good player, think he will play a big part this season for united.
04/07/2008 11:37:00
he was the best english midfielder last season and somehow capello doesnt pick him.
04/07/2008 21:11:00
Suffering an attack of delusion there, RIG? BTW, I thought you hate Scousers? If so, why do you think a Scouser is God? ;)
05/07/2008 15:33:00
my opinion is that he is better then barry but yet he gets overlooked for the england squad
Lil Carlitos
05/07/2008 16:03:00
i agree, better than barry.
07/07/2008 02:46:00
what he (carrick) is basically trying to say is 'THE NAME ON FRONT OF THE SHIRT IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE ONE ON THE BACK...OR NUMBER FOR THAT MATTER'......i think even with my distaste of ronaldo..coming to think about it...hes the only player i dont like....i think you have currently the best midfield combo in carrick and scholes....(dont stare i may be a spurs fan but i love football...whoever plays it)
17/07/2008 12:48:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester United Articles

United Target Happy Where He Is Claim

Continuing, as you do, on defensive matters, the media have reported that Manchester United have expressed an interest in a centre-back currently playing in Serie A.

United Linked to Arsenal Defender

But it could be a forlorn chase for the full-back!

Martial`s Old Trafford Future Questioned

This summer, we`re fully expecting there to be some movement on the player front at Old Trafford.

Sanchez Likened to Di Maria?

As we struggle to keep the journalistic momentum during yet another international break, the form of one player appears to be generating some unwanted column inches.

Manchester United Archived Articles

Vital United articles from

Site Journalists

Red Boy
Editor email
Charlie Bacchus
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

MOTM v Brighton (FA Cup)?
Suggested By: Red Boy
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Manchester United Results (view all)

Manchester United Fixtures

The Vital Football Members League