Manchester United - The Candidates To Replace Vidic
UK time is: 08:27:07
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Candidates To Replace Vidic

United have conceded 15 goals in 32 league games this season. Our incredible defensive solidity is mainly down to the magnificent central pair of Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic.

Now that one of them is out for at least two weeks and three games (Middlesbrough, Roma, Arsenal) we must consider what the candidates to replace him have to offer.

I think we can safely ignore Mikael Silvestre, after all, he's just returned from injury. Hasn't played a competitive game since September, it would be a huge surprise if he was given a substitute appearance let alone a starting role.

Gerard Pique is a very talented player with excellent physical attributes and good positioning. But he's inexperienced and a tad slow - it would be a huge gamble to thrust him into the limelight at such a crucial stage of the campaign.

Therefore, for me, it's really between John O'Shea and Wesley Brown. The former was excellent in Rome and the latter did an unexpectedly solid job all season - at right back.

Brown is probably a bit quicker and has a greater leap. On the other hand, his footballing brain is inferior to that of O'Shea - and I do not try to imply that the Irishman's intelligence compares to that of Zidane or even of Ferdinand. His positioning and understanding of the game is slightly superior to Brown's, that's all.

It looks likely that one of them will replace Vidic for these three games and the other will continue at right-back. However, there is one possible solution that must be looked at.

Many, myself included, feel that playing O'Shea and Brown alongside each other is a bit of a risk. Both of them are fine as full-backs if Rio and Vidic do that excellent job of theirs in the centre. But if both have to be included, the stability and the balance of the back four could be seriously undermined.

So I suggest that we deploy either Brown or O'Shea alongside Rio and play an energetic, quick, hard-tackling player at right-back. That player would be Owen Hargreaves who I believe could help us out at this stage. His credentials as a defensive midfielder are obvious and I often stated that he should start the big games but Scholes, Anderson and Carrick can all do a fine job in those games that we have until Vidic can return.

Of course, it's only a possible solution, nothing else. I'm not certain what should be done and it's far from certain what Fergie will do. It's best to leave it to him though.

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: Zae Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday April 3 2008

Time: 4:53PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
I'm glad he won't be coming up to our place on Sunday, though.
Boro 01
Report Abuse
03/04/2008 20:31:00

Report Abuse
03/04/2008 21:51:00

maybe brown could replace vidic
Report Abuse
03/04/2008 21:58:00

I think John o'shea is your man to replace Vidic.
Report Abuse
03/04/2008 23:21:00

Pique should get in a game or 2 he needs them
Report Abuse
04/04/2008 00:24:00

Brown in the middle and JOS right back although i'd like to see Pique given a chance.
Report Abuse
04/04/2008 00:26:00

I'd go for O'Shea in the middle, Brown on the right. Pique is not ready yet. Maybe he can start the second leg against Roma.
Report Abuse
04/04/2008 09:05:00

just leave oshea there for me
Report Abuse
04/04/2008 19:57:00

I would go for O'Shea too.
Fan of Blues
Report Abuse
07/04/2008 00:15:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester United Articles

Arsenal v United - Stat Attack (Saturday October 3 2015)

Arsenal v United - Early Team-News (Saturday October 3 2015)

Blindfolded? (Saturday October 3 2015)

Van Gaal Praises Smalling`s Development (Saturday October 3 2015)

Martial Interested Another Club! (Saturday October 3 2015)

AUDIO: David Beckham Playlist (Friday October 2 2015)

Young Praise from van Gaal (Friday October 2 2015)

Ronaldo Linked Again, But How! (Friday October 2 2015)

Muller Rumours Were True! (Friday October 2 2015)

Archived Manchester United Articles

List All Vital United Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Man City 8 6 0 2 +12 18
2. Man Utd 7 5 1 1 +7 16
3. Crystal Palace 8 5 0 3 +4 15
4. Leicester City 8 4 3 1 +2 15
5. West Ham 8 4 2 2 +6 14
6. Arsenal 7 4 1 2 +3 13
7. Everton 7 3 3 1 +4 12

Manchester United Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Alex Neil: We Moved The Ball Too Slowly
Norwich : 04/10/2015 08:00:01
The return of Dark clouds to Chelsea FC
Chelsea : 04/10/2015 01:30:00
Pundits Predictions: Swansea City vs Tottenham Hotspur
Swansea : 03/10/2015 22:26:01
Gomes Stars As Hornets Draw At Bournemouth
Watford : 03/10/2015 21:44:01
Watford : 03/10/2015 21:43:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM v Wolfsburg (h)?
Suggested By:  Red Boy
De Gea 6%
Valencia 0%
Smalling 8%
Blind 1%
Darmian 0%
Schneiderlin 1%
Schweinsteiger 9%
Mata 60%
Rooeny 1%
Depay 3%
Martial 9%
Young 1%
Pereira 0%
Jones 1%